Home All SWF Seeking Less Stress: Overcoming an Overthinking, Anticipating, Maximizer Self

SWF Seeking Less Stress: Overcoming an Overthinking, Anticipating, Maximizer Self

written by Suzann Pileggi 27 May 2009

Suzann Pileggi, MAPP '08, is a wellness writer and consultant. She is a monthly columnist for the International Positive Psychology Association (IPPA) newsletter and Wisdom magazine, and a certified holistic health counselor. Suzann's website.

Suzann's articles are here.

Since the theme of this month is stress and resilience I spent some time pondering ways to lighten my daily burden. I took a long hard look at my life and noticed that I place much undo stress and pressure upon myself. I coined a phrase that captures my daily life: I’m an overthinking anticipating maximizer . Much of my stress is self-induced. Discovering this phrase was an exhilarating “a-ha” moment for me. Surely, this ritualized pattern of living isn’t written in stone; rather, it’s a collection of learned habits. While it will take practice, I now see that I can unlearn them by replacing them with healthier habits to decrease my stress and enhance my state of mind.

Let’s break down the phrase and take a brief look at each of the three words that best define my habits.


Women Who Think Too MuchFor rational human beings, thinking is critical to life. However, too much of a good thing, like fine wine and chocolate (two of my personal favorites!), may hurt us. Thinking in excess can be toxic. In her book, Women Who Think Too Much, University of Michigan psychologist Susan Nolen-Hoeksema defines overthinking as “getting caught in torrents of negative thoughts and emotions that overwhelm us and interfere with our functioning and well-being.” Overthinking can be detrimental to health.

Due to the rapid speed and unpleasant destinations my mind often travels at any given moment, especially in stressful times, I should qualify for the gold standard in frequent flyer miles. Whereas someone who doesn’t struggle with overthinking can easily get from point A to point B, my mind appears to take the circuitous route, with many detours, delays, and dips in the road. I get so exhausted from thinking alone that the term a “mental holiday” is something I cherish. While my daily physical jog is challenging it nowhere compares with the exhausting mental race I run every day.

According to Nolen-Hoeksema, overcoming overthinking is like trying to escape from quicksand. She recommends three steps to cease the habit: breaking the grip of your thoughts so they don’t continue to sink you down; moving to higher ground where you can see things in a broader perspective; and avoiding future traps. Her book delineates a set of practical strategies for accomplishing each of these three steps. Engage in pleasant distractions. Adjust your focus. Abandoning unhealthy goals. Personally, I find that taking time for myself, slowing down to savor, and meditating are daily habits that help me tame my out-of-control thinker.


University of Loyola’s Dr. Fred Bryant depicts anticipating the future as one of the three temporal forms of savoring, along with reminiscing about the past, and in-the-moment relishing. As a natural anticipator, and a zestful person, I’m often ebullient about upcoming positive events. However, at the same time, this attention towards the future can equally bring me much unwarranted worry when confronting uncertainty. Since I tend to look ahead, rather look than back or revel in-the-moment, I often get stuck on the negative “what-ifs.”

During Dr. Karen Reivich’s Resiliency Training Workshop at the University of Pennsylvania last summer, I learned about the underlying emotional states, e.g. anger, sadness, guilt, anxiety, etc. that impact people’s behaviors. I immediately related to the state of anxiety, and then made a connection to my strong anticipatory nature. Truly an “a-ha” moment for me, I pondered: Could my often anxious state be related to my focus on the future? Perhaps, if I focused more “on-the-moment” by redirecting my attention from the future to what I could do in the here-and-now, I could decrease unnecessary anxiety, and take better control of my thoughts and rein in my stress.


According to definitions by University of Swarthmore psychologist Barry Schwartz, I’m a solid maximizer who always wants to make the best choice as opposed to a satisficer who accepts good enough .

Schwartz doesn’t know what makes one a maximizer but thinks it is perhaps impacted by where someone lives. New York City, my home, prides itself on choice. You can do whatever you want, whenever you want – whether it’s Greek or Thai food you’re seeking, or belly dancing or bowling, you can do it whenever you want. Even with yoga, my respite from a life in overdrive, I’m presented with so many options. Do I take Bikram, Vinyasa, or Ashtanga? The energy it takes to make the choice is almost not worth the trouble. But it sure keeps the yoga studios in business and anxiety prescriptions soaring since restoring peace of mind is what is needed after evaluating all of our choices. I often end up doing nothing because of the all the energy I exert on just deciding, a concept Schwartz refers to as “paralysis by analysis.” Research shows that while maximizers may make marginally better choices than satisficers, they end up feeling worse about what they choose and they experience more stress.

Changing Into a “Thinking Just Enough, In-the-moment Satisficer”

Together, my tendency to overthink, anticipate and maximize creates a pattern of over analysis, pesky anxious thoughts, and nagging self-doubt where I’m constantly wondering how I could do better.

Fortunately, gratitude is my top signature strength. By reframing a situation and looking at what I have to be thankful for, I can decrease my tendency to overthink, dwell on the future, and always seek the best. Instead, I plan to:

  1. Take Dr. Schwartz’ advice to only spend more time on making choices about the things that matter most in my life
  2. Be more mindful of the present and what I can do now
  3. Transition to becoming a “satisficer” in most areas of my life

As I stop being a stressed-out overthinking, anticipating maximizer and become a thinking-just-enough in-the-moment satisficer, I move closer to the serene life that I truly desire.

Books to read more

Bryant, F. & Veroff, J. (2007) Savoring: A new model of positive experience.. Mahwah, New Jersey: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

Nolen-Hoeksema, S. (2003). Women Who Think Too Much: How to Break Free of Overthinking and Reclaim Your Life. New York: Owl Books.

Schwartz, B. (2004). The Paradox of Choice: Why More Is Less. New York: Ecco.

Looking for other flowers by diskychick

Not seeing the pictures for the book links? Disable Adblocking for this site to view them.

You may also like


Christine Duvivier 27 May 2009 - 3:38 pm

Hi Suzie, what a great article, thank you! You’re much too natural, funny and charming to be doing much overthinking/maximizing, but in any case you give all of us great food-for-thought.

All the best,

Marie-Josee Salvas 27 May 2009 - 4:43 pm

Overthinking anticipating maximizer – your title immediately caught my attention because I’m right with you on this. Two questions:
1- would you still be an overthinker if you weren’t a maximizer? I’m wondering if only tackling the maximizing part would lead to the same results.
2- I wonder if turning into an in-the-moment satisficer would still fulfill your future orientation. I know that for myself, one of my top Strengthsfinder themes is Futuristic, so I wouldn’t want to lose sight of this.

Denise Q 27 May 2009 - 5:35 pm

Hi Suzie,
Great article – thank you! I like how you linked your anticipatory savouring to your future anxiety. In response to MJ’s comment, I think it’s possible to keep the futuristic/anticipatory behaviour – but once you’ve got there and felt that excitement or whatever, then it’s helpful to bring it back and ground it in the present with Suzie’s present-focused ‘what can I do about this right now’ or ‘what do I need to attend to right now that will help me move toward that future’.

As a chronic day dreamer I need to do this regularly.

I’m anticipating seeing you all in June [but better get some work done here and now!]

Suzie 27 May 2009 - 7:04 pm

Aww…thanks for your lovely comments and compliments, Christine! I really appreciate it!:)

I’m glad you enjoyed my article.


Suzie 27 May 2009 - 7:18 pm

MarieJ, my fellow “OAM”!

You bring up some great comments.
I think that even if I weren’t a
maximizer, I’d still be an overthinker.
While lost of my maximizing tendencies
naturally cause me to overthink, I also
overthink about decisions/things in life
that don’t necessarily have to do with being
the best. It’s more of just overanalyzing things,
ideas to death!

Regarding your second comment, I think Denise eloquently
addressed it in her response. I think the ability to shift between time perspectives is very important and an interesting area of current research in positive psychology. I interviewed Dr. Bryat on savoring in the IPPA May newsletter about it and Ilona Boniwell in the July issue if you want to check them out. Of course, Phil Zimbardo’s work in time perspectives is applicable here.

Suzie 27 May 2009 - 7:21 pm


Thank you for your wonderful feedback and insight.

From one anticipator to another, I can’t wait to see you in June!


aaron jarden 28 May 2009 - 5:49 pm

Hi Suzie, great peice. If you havent read Carl Honore’s book “in praise of slowness’, his approach will also help with these three things in particular (yes, even for making better choices). But if you do Yoga, you already prob get half the benifits from slowing down while practicing yoga anyway…

Or see Carl’s talk on TED.com

Cheers, Aaron.

Added by PPND editor:

Suzie Pileggi 28 May 2009 - 9:21 pm


Thanks for your note. I’m glad you enjoyed my article.
I have not read Carl Honore’s book. I will definitely check
it out. Thanks for the heads-up! Although I’ve been an avid yogi
for 9 years, I could use even more slowing down!!!

Thanks again!


Senia 29 May 2009 - 8:28 am

Suzie, your specifics are so much fun to read: “Due to the rapid speed and unpleasant destinations my mind often travels at any given moment, especially in stressful times, I should qualify for the gold standard in frequent flyer miles.” and “mental holiday.” Plus I like that in the comments, you’re comfortable with the new term “OAM”! Thanks!

Suzie 29 May 2009 - 3:46 pm

Thanks Senia!

I’m glad you found my article “fun.” I try to make light of my shortcomings — they’re much easier to deal with that way , then if I take myself TOO SERIOUS! 🙂

Louis Alloro 2 June 2009 - 9:09 am

Awesome Suzie! Your candor is an excellent reminder that OAM affects many of us – and that consciousness (mindfulness Wayne!) is the first step. Bravo for taking it!

I went to a wedding a few weeks ago where the best man said of the groom “Jake is the type of guy who leads from the heart and worries about the details later.” I thought, “That’s why Jake’s so cool. I want to be like Jake.”

With Jake-like love,

Suzie 2 June 2009 - 10:01 am

Thanks for your wonderful comments, Louis! Yes, I believe
that mindfulness is key!!! I wrote about it awhile back for PPND — I think it was one of my first articles. And, I wrote a paper on mindfulness for the assignment Chris Peterson gave us at MAPP on the “25th VIA Character Strength.”

Wayne provides great info. on mindfulness and I bought his software. Now, if I could just pause for a moment to take advantage of his free coaching workshop on the software that would be terrific!

Jake sounds cool, Louis.
And, YOU, are WAY COOL! 🙂


WJ 2 June 2009 - 4:51 pm

Louis, awareness is only one aspect of mindfulness. You can cultivate all the awareness in the world, but without acceptance it probably won’t bare much fruit.

WJ 2 June 2009 - 4:53 pm

Is it possible to get a copy of your paper on mindfulness as the 25th character strengh?

Suzie 10 June 2009 - 1:48 pm

Sure, Wayne. Just need to find it first! :)Will hunt for it post First World Congress on Positive Psychology

Kathryn Britton 10 June 2009 - 4:58 pm

Hey, Suzie, how about publishing your twenty-fifth strength paper here?

Maybe we should make that the optional theme for July.

I think I still have mine somewhere — on patience and endurance.



Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

WP Twitter Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com