Home All Health Habits Work Better Together: Evidence from the Transtheoretical Model

Health Habits Work Better Together: Evidence from the Transtheoretical Model

written by Marie-Josée Shaar 17 September 2014
Fruits and vegetables

Marie-Josée (MJ) Salvas Shaar, MAPP '07, CPT, has studied, tested, coached, and taught smart health habits for over 13 years. Combining positive psychology with fitness and nutrition, she created a coaching method that builds better sleep, food, mood, and exercise habits, as described in her book, Smarts and Stamina: The Busy Person's Guide to Optimal Health and Performance, which includes 50 practical health-building activities. Today MJ gives keynotes for corporate wellness programs and offers continuing education for wellness professionals, who can license her Smarts and Stamina Online program. Full bio. MJ's articles are here.

Would you consider sending your child to a school that covers the whole K-12 English curriculum in grades 1, 2 and 3, all of math in grades 4, 5 and 6, history in grade 7, geography in grade 8, biology in grade 9, and so on?

Of course not! Kids need to learn different skills at the same time because one reinforces the other. Strong language skills help a child understand math problems, and strong math skills help with science puzzles.

Similarly, your child’s maturity grows over time, and with that, his or her ability to understand complexity also grows. Shakespeare, Einstein, Newton, and Lincoln’s contributions are unlikely to be fully grasped by a 7 year old.

Academic ability is therefore like a puzzle where all the pieces fit together, and the challenge levels need to match the maturity levels of the students.

The same goes for our health skills. Maturity also plays a role here. We need to learn how to walk before we can run, we need to learn how to cook at home before we can definitively trash junk food, and we need to control momentary emotional impulses before we can successfully meditate through chaos. When we eat and sleep well, we have active minds which bolster our moods, and we have active bodies that give us the energy to enjoy exercise. Being active makes it easier to fall asleep. Health skills go together and grow together.

Simultaneous Growth Applies to Health Promotion

The fact that most wellness programs promote either food or exercise habits in isolation puzzles me. We intuitively know that when we sleep poorly, we are drawn to snacking and overeating. We also know that nothing gets rid of a crappy mood faster than a good sweat and that lower stress levels contribute to a better night’s sleep. So why are so many programs treating sleep, food, mood, and exercise as if they were separate topics?

Those who have been part of the Smarts and Stamina community know where I’m going with this: our sleep, food, mood, and exercise habits are mutually reinforcing, not only because of how they make us feel subjectively, but also because of the biochemical activity that each generates in the body. For more information on this, check out our health promotion model.

“The message feels fresh and new to me: each of these habits is interdependent on the rest, but that there are ways to exploit those interdependencies, so that you build successes on other successes rather than trying and failing. Of course, it makes so much sense that I’m surprised it felt so new.” ~ Lilly Bradford in a review of Smarts and Stamina

Transtheoretical Model Trend: Working on Multiple Health Behaviors at Once

James O. Prochaska wrote in 2008 that interventions that try to change multiple health behaviors either simultaneously or sequentially are likely to be the future of preventive medicine. He introduces the idea of co-variation, also called co-action.

“Co-variation occurs when taking effective action on one behavior increases the odds of taking effective action on a second behavior. This phenomenon is different from co-occurrence where groups of particular behaviors are more likely to have higher prevalence in particular populations… Co-variation reflects behaviors changing together rather than behaviors occurring together.” ~ J. O. Prochaska

A recent paper by Sara Johnson and colleagues investigated co-action in three different studies. They found substantial evidence that co-action occurs, at least in the context of interventions based on the transtheoretical model.

In one study, participants were randomized to either usual care or interventions targeting up to three behaviors: healthy eating, regular exercise, and managing emotions without eating. Participants in the intervention group then received tailored reports providing feedback on their stage of change for each behavior (Precontemplation, Contemplation, Preparation, or Action), self-efficacy, and a few related topics. Following the results for up to 24 months, the study found that participants were roughly twice as likely as the control group to take action on a second behavior. To quote James Prochaska again, “Co-variation represents one innovative approach in which effective change on one treated behavior increases the odds of effective action on a second targeted behavior.”

Why does co-action occur? Here are some of the hypothesized reasons mentioned by Johnson and colleagues.

  • Increases in self-efficacy from changing one behavior spill over and help people change another behavior.
  • Knowledge and skills learned from making one change transfer to making the other change.
  • Making one behavior habitual might free up self-regulatory resources to work on another behavior.
  • Individualized interventions based on the transtheoretical model may be particularly well suited to support co-action.

More research is needed to explore what makes co-action occur. Is it specific to the transtheoretical model, or can it occur in other contexts and approaches?

How to Be Healthy

People ask me every day how they can become healthier. Here’s my answer.

Start with whatever is easiest for you instead of what’s most difficult. If you have a hard time with your food habits (you wouldn’t be the only one!), then food is your problem, not your solution. Work on sleep, mood, and/or exercise first, and food will become less of a challenge. You’ll get the ball rolling, feel in control and capable of change, and quickly build on initial victories. That’s much more energizing and sustainable than trying to fix your weakest area first.

For clear strategies on how to tackle each of sleep, food, mood, and exercise, check out our book. It offers 50 research-based avenues to better health.


Shortlist of Sources

Johnson, S., Paiva, A., Mauriello, L., Prochaska, J., Redding, C., Velicer, W. (2014). Coaction in multiple behavior change interventions: Consistency across multiple studies on weight management and obesity prevention. Health Psychology. 33 (5), 475–480. Abstract.

Prochaska, J. (2008). Multiple Health Behavior Research represents the future of preventive medicine. Preventive Medicine, 46(3), 281–285. Abstract.

Shaar, M.J. & Britton, K. (2011). Smarts and Stamina: The Busy Person’s Guide to Optimal Health and Performance. Philadelphia, PA: Positive Psychology Press.

Image Credits
Still puzzled courtesy of Roberta Romagnoli / wererabbit
Being physically active courtesy of Nick-K (Nikos Koutoulas)
Fruits and vegetables courtesy of Hellebardius

Not seeing the pictures for the book links? Disable Adblocking for this site to view them.

You may also like

1 comment

Peter Nicholls 18 September 2014 - 5:41 pm

An excellent article and I endorse the thrust of what you have said. I would simply add that you reflect a traditional message that the way to reduce stress is to undertake physical exercise {“a good sweat”). I would emphasise the fact that stress is a mental issue and mental illness affects a fifth of a typical western population.

The answer is more than simply physical exercise (important though that is) but in any pursuit – physical or mental – that one enjoys. Mine is singing in a choir, but that’s just me. Only if you enjoy physical exercise will it be and stay part of your ongoing health program (only a quarter of western people regularly exercise for enjoyment).

When you lose yourself in any interest you love, you find yourself – the real you comes alive, increasing energy, self esteem, self confidence and the sense of self worth.

Finally let me give you my definition of leisure/recreation after over 30 years of working in that field: Leisure is any experience in which you creatively express your natural talents primarily for the intrinsic pleasure that the experience gives you.

Thanks for the opportunity to comment and please keep up your good work.


Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

WP Twitter Auto Publish Powered By : XYZScripts.com