Meaning Can Come from Suffering AND Play

When you think of the meaning of your life, do you think of making it, searching for it, finding it, or noticing it? Do you associate meaning with times of well-being or do you believe meaning becomes apparent primarily in times of suffering?

These were points of difference among the keynote speakers at the 7th Biennial Meaning Conference, held in Toronto Canada from 27th through July 29th, 2012. This article covers some of the viewpoints presented on day 1 of the conference. A subsequent article will cover days 2 and 3.

Emmy van Deurzen: The Meaning of Suffering

Dr. Emmy van Deurzen is an existential psychologist honored at the conference with a Lifetime Achievement Award. In the keynote that opened the conference, she described life as a whirlwind of change and explored ways that people find steadiness, resilience, and purpose in that context. Suffering is universal, and people need to learn to deal with it rather than finding ways to avoid facing it. She referenced Viktor Frankl’s structure for meaning:

• Experiential: What we take from the world
• Creative: What we give to the world
• Additudinal: The way we deal with suffering

Citing Camus, she stated that meaning is found because of challenges in life, not in spite of them.

She also stated that the art of living is to be equal to all of our emotions, rather than to select or cultivate only the pleasant ones.

Robert Neimeyer: The Narrative Arc of a Tragic Loss

Psychologist Robert Neimeyer studies grieving as a process of reconstructing meaning after it has been challenged by loss. He sketched the narrative arc of grieving, describing how a person’s story is shattered, retold, reconstructed, integrated, and extended. Using video-clips of mothers who have lost children to violence, he showed how predictability, sense of worth, and personal ability to protect families are often called into question. Some people are resilient, but others face complicated spiritual grief including persistent despair and withdrawal from faith communities.

Neimeyer referenced the work of Katherine Shear, whose center runs randomized clinical trials of various treatment approaches for complicated grief. He also discussed the effective use of narrative interventions that involved benefit finding, sensemaking, and emotional disclosure, all of which gave people temporary respite and still showed benefits after 3 months.

George Bonanno: Trauma, Meaning, and Flexibility
I encountered psychologist George Bonanno when I was writing Grief is a Part of Life, as I was grieving the loss of a second friend in less than a year. He had written a book called The Other Side of Sadness that my group found very helpful.

In preparation for this keynote, Bonanno had taken a good hard look at the literature about meaning. He asked himself the following 5 questions and found literature with partial answers:

1. Is meaning making necessary and adaptive? He referred us to Crystal Park’s meta-analysis, which has a decidedly mixed answer, which could be summarized as “Often yes, but sometimes no.”
2. Does it change over time? He explored when people meaning of an event, right afterwards when it is most salient or later. Social sharing appears to occur mostly within a week or so after an event. Meaning making at a greater time distance can lead to greater reflection and more elaborate meaning-making, if it doesn’t become rumination. Resilient people tend to under-remember the details of the adverse event, a process that may be a normal part of health.
3. Is it the same for everyone? People have different ways of responding to loss. In studies he referenced concerning responses to adverse events, some experience chronic suffering (5-30%), others delayed responses or deterioration (0-15%), but a surprisingly large number experience recovery (15-25%) or resilience (35-65%).
4. Does the type of event matter? Do isolated potentially traumatic events have different impacts than chronic stressors? Some studies find that people have a harder time making meaning of chronic challenges.
5. What other risks or resilience factors affect the way people respond to life stressors?

In the context of the final question, Dr. Bonanno ended his talk with a discussion of coping flexibility. There is no such thing as a single perfect adaptation to life: every adaptation has its pluses and minuses. He sketched what he believes to be the most successful way to face life’s challenges:

• Maintaining a broad repertoire of possible responses to challenges: The repertoire might include talking, distracting oneself, writing, finding ways to laugh about it, doing something to change the situation, deep breathing, and so on.
• Appraising the situation: What happened? How am I coping?
• Selecting a particular response from the repertoire
• Being attentive to feedback: Is this doing any good? Should I do more of it? Should I try another strategy?

Mark Kingwell: The Art of Play

Starting with the statement that life could be lived as if it were a work of art, philosopher Kingwell explored 5 dimensions of the art of play:

1. Time: shifting time, finding ways to escape from time as a currency that is spent and saved
2. Pretending, inventing an alternate reality, such as a little girl pretending to feed a teddy bear: games with no particular end in mind
3. Finite Games: play organized to reach some sort of conclusion, played by rules
4. Outcomes: wisdom-producing, body disciplining, status
5. Infinite Games: no purpose beyond the game itself, good move keeps the game going

Poetry and philosophy are infinite games. He concluded that the highest forms of play open us up to the most divine, that which is closest to immortality.

Viktor and I: the movie

Many speakers invoked Viktor Frankl over the course of the weekend. His book, Man’s Search for Meaning, is a central text in discussions of meaning. So it wasn’t surprising that the Biennial Meaning Conference included a showing of a movie, Viktor and I, that celebrates his eventful and fruitful life. The movie included recordings of speeches by Frankl as well as numerous interviews with people who felt their lives had been enriched by his presence. There were stories of his stage presence, moral courage, and physical courage, including Frankl’s passion for mountain climbing. Frankl joined my personal pantheon of people whose lives are examples to live by.

What was surprising was the warmth, humor, even whimsy that resonated throughout the film. Frankl’s granddaughter described him playing with them at bedtime, his two feet under the bedsheets having comical conversations with each other. His grandson, Alexander Vesely, commented that his grandfather collected jokes the way other people collect postage stamps. Vesely directed the movie and introduced it for the conference, perhaps a bit shyly, preferring to let the work speak for itself. In the discussion after the movie, Vesely noted that Frankl discouraged ranking the suffering of different people. Children can feel great pain when they experience losses that the adults around them find trivial. He also reminded the audience that his grandfather took a stand against collective guilt. Frankl felt that you cannot demand heroism from anyone but yourself.

More to Come

On the second and third days, other views of meaning were expressed by speakers including Christopher Peterson, Laura King, Richard Ryan, and Paul Wong. Come back to follow me to the everyday side of meaning and beyond.
 

---

 
References

Bonanno, G. (2009). The Other Side of Sadness: What the New Science of Bereavement Tells Us About Life After Loss. Basic Books.

Frankl, V. (1959). Man’s Search For Meaning. New York: Simon and Schuster.

Kingwell, M. (2000). In Pursuit of Happiness: Better Living from Plato to Prozac. Crown Books.

Lichtenthal, W. G., & Cruess, D. G. (2010). Effect of directed written disclosure on grief and distress symptoms among bereaved individuals. Death Studies, 34, 475-499.

Lichtenthal, W. G., Currier, J. M., Neimeyer, R. A. & Keesee, N. J. (2010). Sense and significance: A mixed methods examination of meaning making after the loss of one’s child. Journal of Clinical Psychology 66(7): 791-812.

Neimeyer, R. (2006). Lessons of Loss: A Guide to Coping. Center for the Study of Loss and Transition.

Park, C. (2010). Making sense of the meaning literature: An integrative review of meaning making and its effects on adjustment to stressful life events. Psychological Bulletin, 136(2), 257-301. Abstract.

van Deurzen, E. (2010). Everyday Mysteries: A Handbook of Existential Psychotherapy, Second Edition. Routledge.

Vesely, A. & Noetic Films (2011). Viktor and I

Images
Most images are from the Biennial Meaning site.
Viktor & I cover is from Noetic Films.
Cats at play courtesy of Malingering

Edited by Natasha Utevsky