When do you have your greatest insights? Do they arrive when you’re intensely focused on a goal or solution? Or, do they tend to emerge when you’re calm and relaxed?
Funny thing is, we tend to do exactly what the research tells us not to do.
Common Practice versus ResearchFor example, let’s say you’ve been asked to submit a proposal to a prospective client. It’s late in the day and you’re just beginning to fill in your company’s background information, but you can’t seem to coherently string together your ideas. You begin to get frustrated. Instead of calling it a day, or, at the very least, taking a break, you stay at your desk and force yourself to keep at it until you arrive at a “perfectly” clear and concise response.
Now, let’s flip to what the research tells us. Even though it seems like a great idea at the time to push yourself to the nth degree, this kind of extreme focus and control can greatly undermine your ability to achieve the outcome you desire most, a clear, concise, and creative response.
As a matter of fact, research by Daniel Wegner, a psychology professor at Harvard, explains the nuances of this dilemma. Daniel adopted a theory called ironic process, which suggests that the mind will unconsciously search for an unwanted mental state. In this instance, we accidentally engender a narrow, limiting perspective when we pour energy into fostering a creative mindset.
Along the same lines, neuroscience research has shown we have our greatest moments of insight and creativity when the mind is calm and relaxed. You probably didn’t need me to remind you of that! Have you ever had a moment of clarity or insight in the shower? What about while spending time in nature? Isn’t it ironic that withdrawing your focus from the goal or problem actually facilitates insight?Using Moments of Stress to Remember to be Calm
I recognize many of us are required, all right maybe conditioned, to spend heaps of time at our computers, but this truly isn’t where our greatest moments of insight occur. One of the best things you can do is give your mind – and your brain – a break from such a diligent outward focus. Allow it to rest and recover the same way you would your biceps if you were engaging in a strength-training regime.
When I first discovered this research, it caused me to reflect on my own work habits. I could see places where I’d unknowingly fallen into the trap of overworking and overthinking in an attempt to cross one more thing off my to-do list. After becoming aware of this habit, I began to use moments of stress, rushing, and confusion as reminders to slow down, take a breather, and draw my attention inward. Sometimes I would step outdoors to feel the breeze on my skin or listen to the cacophony of birds. Other times, I’d simply close my eyes and feel the natural rhythm of my breath. In any case, I discovered that allowing myself to shift my focus away from the task at hand naturally brought on a sense of ease that facilitated greater insight down the road.
Consider Doing the Opposite of What’s ExpectedCertain work habits run deep in our culture. To name a few: Work ourselves to exhaustion, don’t take breaks, stare down a problem until you reach a solution, multitask, and do more in less time. Sometimes these habits are both necessary and effective. But more times than not, I see people unconsciously operating from these principles without carefully considering the impact on their inner state and outer performance.
Upon asking if such habits enhance efficiency or effectiveness, most immediately respond with a “No.” So while my advice may seem a little odd, I do believe that we can both quiet stress and enhance creative problem solving by doing the exact opposite of what we think we should do. Namely, ease up on yourself about checking everything off your to-do list, take breaks (I mean, really take them), shift your focus away from a complex problem before settling on a solution, unitask, and slow down every once in a while!
References
Wegner, D. M., Schneider, D. J., Carter, S., & White, T. (1987). Paradoxical effects of thought suppression. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 53, 5-13.
Wegner, D. M. & Pennebaker, J. W. (1992). The Handbook Of Mental Control. Pearson.
Wegner, D. M. (2011). Setting free the bears:Escape from thought suppression. American Psychologist,66, 671-680.
Daniel Wegner’s publication list
Photo Credit: via Compfight with Creative Commons licenses
Fat light bulb courtesy of Bes Z
Shower courtesy of kevin dooley
Bird sounds courtesy of Mr.TinDC
4 comments
Creativity blossoms when we use loving kindness. Barb Fredrickson will enjoy your spot-on article, Breon. Mindfulness based stress reduction is terrific for openness up self-awareness and letting our brain focus on flexibility via lighter moments rather than drive drive drive. Not a great way to thrive.
Excuse me, I was going to write more, but you reminded me I need to take a break and enjoy my garden. Pause to open up the portals of my mind.
Bless you!
Hi Breon – a lovely article, thank you. I particularly liked this reminder “ease up on yourself”. I attended a Mindful Leadership Retreat in March 2010 led by Saki Santorelli and Janice Marturano. Your article reminded me of something Janice said when she was trying to explain the benefits of taking space, making time for quiet. She commented that innovators know this concept, it’s just what they do. It’s innate for them. What I took away from that was not to deliberately set aside space so that in that space an idea arises, but to regularly make spaces for no good reason.
This is a great post.
Two weeks ago I restructured my day from all work, and then activites such as the gym, walking the dog and showering in the evening, but now I intersperse them throughout my day.
I spend most of my day writing. The amount of ideas I would get during the gym when I moved it to 12pm was CRAZY.
If anyone has control over their day or works from home, then Breon’s advice is a must hear
Bless you, too, Judy! Your response made me laugh out loud. I appreciate the nod to loving kindness. Barb’s work is incredibly nourishing. I’m a big fan of Sharon Salzberg’s work on loving kindness, too.
Thank you, Amanda! Such a great reminder about deliberately creating more space in our day, rather than constantly operating from a place of urgency and automaticity. I, too, have been lucky enough to retreat with Janice and Saki. Their work is deeply inspiring!
Finally, what a beautiful example, Tom! How neat that you gave yourself permission to restructure your day in such a way…. and even better you’ve found that it unleashes your creativity!