Parenting & Schools
Business
Happiness Exercises
Health
Relationships
Home » All, Strength 25th, Strengths

Should the 25th Strength be Global or Local?

By on July 8, 2009 – 11:04 am  4 Comments

Denise Quinlan, MAPP '08, is a trainer with the Penn Resiliency Program and Strath Haven Positive Psychology Curriculum and is currently a PhD student focusing on strengths and subjective well being. She has over twenty years experience in management consulting. Helping people discover strengths and what makes life worth living is what Denise enjoys most, that and the joy of a good theory. Full bio. Denise's articles are here.



Strengths Overlaid

Strengths for Different Realities

Global strengths, such as the 24 strengths of the VIA, are those which are valued by almost every culture in the world. We recognise the importance of these strengths and virtues and they highlight our shared humanity. Local strengths, in contrast, are a product of culture and historical circumstance. They represent a local solution to a local challenge or situation.

Local strengths are not irrelevant just because they are not universal. They acknowledge and arise out of the unique circumstances of a particular culture and create solutions that work there, but might not apply anywhere else. One size doesn’t fit all – even with the VIA. So what I’m arguing for is that rather than picking a 25th universal strength, we should look to our own cultures and identify the local or culturally-bound strengths that have most shaped our culture.

The 1st World Congress of Positive Psychology highlighted the importance of context and culture in understanding well-being. Various presentations emphasised differences between what constitutes happiness and well-being even between European countries and between Europe and India. We learned that in South Korea character strengths may at times conflict with Confucian values, and that where this occurs, the latter will often win out.

Local strengths may need to evolve and change with the culture. While the VIA’s character strengths have enduring value, a local strength may outlive its sell-by date or become ‘over-developed’. Korean ‘filial piety’ is sometimes at odds with ‘modern’ values of justice and honesty creating moral dilemmas for young Koreans. US individualism untrammelled may undermine collective strengths of citizenship and belonging. As well as noticing our local strengths it may be useful to ask, ‘Are they still relevant and useful in dealing with the challenges we now face as a culture?’

It may be easier to identify a local strength when one is a foreigner. Outsiders may notice a ‘national strength’ that has disappeared.

Kiwi Ingenuity

Kiwi Ingenuity

New Zealand’s pioneering history and geographical isolation gave rise to the strengths of ‘she’ll be right’ (every pioneer had to be prepared to turn their hand to any task), and ‘number 8 wire technology’ (almost any repair can be carried out using No.8 fencing wire). Both strengths reflect a rugged self-reliance and ingenuity born of necessity. While ‘Kiwi ingenuity’ is still apparent in some areas of technology, a younger generation brought up on cheap, readily available imported consumer goods is losing the ‘can do’ create or repair strengths of their forefathers.

Dubliners Showing Up

Dubliners Showing Up

The strength of ‘showing up’ was highly valued in Ireland until recent years. Showing up was a strength of belonging: of respecting the group one belonged to and being there for the people who mattered in your life when it mattered to them. As a colonized country, respect for legal authority was scarce in Ireland and most institutions were regarded as illegitimate. Showing up suited the Irish context in that it blended loyalty and citizenship with the freedom to exercise one’s own social intelligence; it allowed for expressions of citizenship and belonging outside institutions (citizenship for the anarchy-inclined). As Ireland has modernized and become wealthier and more individualistic, this strength has broken down and matters less important to socially and geographically mobile younger generations.

The VIA demonstrates that there are universal strengths valued over time by all people. There are also local strengths which, for good or ill, have shaped our cultures. Perhaps we should take stock of our local strengths as well as our global or universal strengths and consider how they may help or hinder us in facing the future.
 


 

References

Peterson, C. & Seligman, M. (2004). Character strengths and virtues: A handbook and classification.. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Two presentations at 1st World Congress on Positive Psychology, Philadelphia, USA, June 18-21, 2009.

  • Antonella Delle Fave, Preclinical Sciences LITA Vialba, University of Milano, Milano, Italy. The Contents and Contexts of Happiness.
  • Yong-Lin Moon, South Korea. The Role and Contribution of Positive Psychology to the Korean Context. See related article, Frames of Meaning for Life.


Images
Positive influence courtesy of Art Makes Me Smile. The three images are Miep Gies, who helped hide Anne Frank’s family, Nelson Mandela, and Mother Teresa.
Kiwi Ingenuity courtesy of Sandy Austin
Wirelings in Dublin courtesy of Matt McGee

4 Comments »

  • Editor S.M. says:

    Denise! This is extremely interesting. I like that you argue that the 25th strength – if it existed – may need to be local to a country.
    There is research by Jennifer Aaker about the brand identities of brands, and she found that brand identities differ somewhat from country to country.

    For example, while honesty, ruggedness, and sophistication are some of the brand themes in America, “ruggedness” does not make it’s way into the brand themes in Europe or in Asia. Additionally, “sophistication” is not a necessary theme in Europe because most products demonstrate sophistication. Similarly “calmness” is a value held in Japan, but not in Europe or America.

    I am intrigued by your argument.
    What do you think might be an American local strength?

    Best,
    Senia

  • Dana says:

    Hi Denise,

    Thanks for your article, I was particularly intrigued by your thought that foreigners can perhaps identify a country’s strength better than a local person or insider.

    As an “extranjera” living in Buenos Aires, it’s evident to me that Argentines spend a lot more time socializing than Americans do, spending hours talking over coffee, wine, and mate (a shared tea, a custom that particularly highlights their sociability). Perhaps Argentina’s history of political and economic instability has created a context where people get together a lot more, for support and as a buffer against such instability.

    It’s such a part of their culture that perhaps its more evident as a strength to me, than it is to them. However, when I’ve asked quite a few local friends about this sociable tendency, they agree that it’s something unique and beneficial about their culture…

    Thanks for provoking an interesting and cross-cultural discussion!
    Dana

  • Patricia says:

    Hi Denise and Dana,
    Being an Argentine myself I totally agree with Dana.Socializing is part of our culture.We find gathering around with friends something important to our daily life.I consider it a strength,since it lets us go over hard times, especially during recession and nowadays with the influenza.
    Thanks Dana for yur kind comments about my country
    Cross-cultural discussion is important to know more about the world we live in
    Patricia

  • Readers,
    Denise’s article has just been updated with definitions for local and global strengths. If you wondered when you first read it what she meant, check it out now.
    Kathryn

Leave a comment!

Add your comment below, or trackback from your own site. You can also subscribe to these comments via RSS.

Be nice. Keep it clean. Stay on topic. No spam.

You can use these tags:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

This is a Gravatar-enabled weblog. To get your own globally-recognized-avatar, please register at Gravatar.